Customer Comments

We try and give out our comment book to everybody with the bill. If you open the album, you will be able to see some of the pages -

Alternatively here are February's comments completely uncensored

Great food. Great value, will be back for wine tasting

Great wine and enjoyable atmosphere. Wonderful service as we arrived twice

Best fillet steak.......ever!

Great flavours. Sole could have been warmer and main course plate hotter!

Food warm enough!

Excellent food, service and atmosphere

Excellent food. Would have liked some bread!! Service excellent

Great food and wine, thank you

5pm deal is excellent value - food very good

Good food - sml portions slightly dark interior doesn't feel very big sur

Choc timbale is choctastic!

2nd visit, and there will be a 3rd. Food, staff and ambience all excellent!

Loved the food. Best fillet steak ever, really! Great wine tasting too. Excellent evening all around

Really interesting urbane wine tasting, fabulously cooked scallops and fillet steak, very light and exquisite dessert - 10/10

Enjoyed the wine tasting - very informative without being stuck up! Food excellent, nicly (????) service, will come again

Delicious food and wine! A real gem! Thanks

Delicious as always!

Always look forward to pancake cheesecake on the same plate

Truely delicious - food so delicious you don't want to swallow!

Where were the pine nuts? Otherwise marveloous stuff, in a lovely setting. A pleasure as always

Great food, fab company. Happy Birthday to me!

Wonderful food with excellent wine selection

Beautiful food, will most definitely be back!

Starters done what starters should... eager for more . mains were excellent. Beautifully cooked lamb... puddings were light but still substantial enough to be a delicious end to a most enjoyable meal. Words are almost reduntant here but palates were dully stimulated... thanks! ... apologies for long windedness...

A very enjoyable meal - well cooked and very tasty. We will be back.

Enjoyed our meals very much.

Great friendly service. Enjoyable food and good wine. Very nice evening.

Great lunch - we'll be back!

Fantastic value for money - delicious food and great service.

A good evening out

A really lovely meal.

A memorable evening

Wonderful food and wine tasting too!

Fantastic tasting of wines. Wonderful food.

Excellent wine, excellent food, would have to come back

Excellent meal. Will definintly come back (awesome)

Perfection as always, always a treat.

Great as always!

Excellent meal and service. Mint!

Top quality. Great value. We will be be back.

1st class. Great value for money. GR8 steaks!!!

Lovely food, great surroundings! Thank you!

Lovely wine and great food. Big fan of the prawns and scallops then the tamali pud - gorgeous!

Excellent food, wine and service. Loved the passion fruit cheesecake. Thanks for a nice dining experience

Very enjoyable

Very nice lunch - will return!

So glad we found you! Delicious! and very helpful staff - great service too! Thank you!!!

Excellent meal, great combination of flavours and really good wine. Will definitely come again. Thanks

Super staff, food and wine. A lovely night, thanks

Es war ein schoner abend. Das essen war wirklich lecker aber dar Kasebuchen hatte besser sein konn. Der wein war sehrishehr lecker!

Fabulouso!! Steak was first class as usual. Too hot for Wendy!!!

Once again, top notch. Thanks

Excellent meal.

Tony wants more! more! more!

You just gotta love the waiting staff here, just like the food he is delicious. Cheers awesome nosh

Very good meal & lovely restaurant. Enjoyed the last year of my special era!

Super again, thanks.

Soup delicious - choice of wine excellent - lamb so so tasty

Thank you for excellent meal and service

Great steak. Good haddock. Would have been better to have choice of green salad.

Fantastic food & glorious Gewurztraminer & Marvelous Merlot. Amazing!

Blandest tasting meal I've ever had

Fab, as always! Tasty, great value, best steak in town xx

Lovely. Next time I'm leaving the car at home!

The food was fantastic, will definitely be back. Thanks!

Splendid. Great service (good banter)

Second time here and still manages to amaze me - superb!! Lovely food, portions just the right size, great quality meat, nice wine list, good value - bit of background music would add nice atmosphere

Very good wine, v average food.

Lovely wine & food. Will be back.

We had a lovely evening as always. Excellent food combined with some great wine.

Lovey food & wine (even though you did like me friend better!!!!?)

Another great meal!

Good wine & service. Did the job.

Great choice of wine. Fillet steak lovely.

Great wine tasting. Lots of choice and very informal and relaxed. Dinner was great too - my butternut squash soup was brilliant!

Lovely evening!

Food excellent.

Very nice great night!

Lovely meal & Great Service

Wine tasting was educational and enjoyable! Dinner was superb and very friendly staff.

Superb food and service

He's here, He's there, he's every f****** where. Up the potters!! It was a nice meal & we're sorry on behalf of Lisa.

Superb

3rd time to Calistoga - everytime is wonderful! Particularly liked the pudding and the wine (MacMurray pinot) Ace! p.s. our waiters jokes were great!

Steaks superb. Small roll with soup would have been nice though.

Lovely food, great service. Very enjoyable night. Thank you very much. We will see you again, p.s. lovely wine selection

Well where do I start? Food great, service brill.

Good food. Good wine. Great idea & service to match. Good luck.

Good! Many thanks. How do your customers find you up this funny little lane?

Excellent as usual - will be back.

Superb! Best meal in ages - picky vegetarian & it was delicious. Husband enjoyed meat too!!!

Excellent as always

Best steak ever & the butter cream sauce was lovely. Service was excellent!

Fabulous food excellent banter. Great service - shame about the veg

Delighted with the whole experience

Second time in 3 days, food superb, moving to Edinburgh!

Can't stop coming back!!

Lovely meal nice service

Fantastic food. Fantastic wine

Most enjoyable experience. Wine tasting great. Food lovely.

First time, excllent meal, service and atmosphere, We'll be back!

11/10 for everything. PS apologies for the noice

The Wine Tasting experience was amazing. I now like red wine. 10/10 to Alastair. Food and service fantatsic! Definitly be back again

Excellent food, nice ambience. Will definitely be back and recommend it to friends.

Superb meal, loved the plumey wine!! Will bring the old ane back soon!! Kind regards!

Great food, service, wine and sourson!. Thoroughly enjoyable evening

Good service, delcious food and excellent wine! Will be back

I'm on my way to sunny California - brillaint

Great food and atmosphere

Very nice food and wine - back soon!

Lovely relaxed meal

Amazing value, well done, better than the south venue

Yum!

Great food! Perfectly balanced. Leaving feeling very content!

Great food. It's been awhile but everything is ace!

Sorry to see Calistoga Southside close, but we had a great night in Central - best of luck! Ta!

Fantastic food, as usual, Brilliant service and a wonderful evening! Loved the Valentines Hearts with each course

Great time wine tasting and meal right up to expectations! Thanks

Drugged on love! Thank you Alastair for a delicious evening and memories if Calistoga.

Happy Valentines!

Steak was great cooked well, red wine + shallot jus - excellent! Lamb was perfect too! We will be back, next time with more time to enjoy the wines!

Meal lovely, thank you

Lovely meal. The Best, well cooked lamb ever. Fantastic service. Cheers